In our guides
Rick and Laura Nifenecker own Café Pierrot, which has two shops in Sussex County: this bakery in Andover and a café in Sparta. Rick studied at Le Cordon Bleu in Paris and the Culinary Institute of America. The bakery makes breads such as country French sourdough, baguette, semolina and rye each morning, along with croissants, turnovers and scones. Custom and celebration cakes, cupcakes, cookies and macarons are made to order.
What’s here
- Made here
- Country French sourdough, baguettes, semolina and rye bread · Croissants, including almond and chocolate · Scones and apple turnovers · Custom and wedding cakes · Cupcakes, decorated cookies and macarons
This season
The 2026 Thanksgiving menu is up: a complete dinner for 10 (carved turkey or sliced breast, sausage stuffing, mashed potatoes, green beans, gravy, cranberry compote, rolls, butternut squash soup) and apple, pumpkin, cherry and chocolate pecan pies. Order online by Saturday, November 21; cold pickup is Wednesday, November 25, 9 AM to 5 PM. Gluten-free pies need a week's notice. Closed Thanksgiving Day.
Good to know
- Where is Café Pierrot?
- 212 Main Street, Andover, NJ 07821, in Sussex County.
- When is Café Pierrot open?
- Monday: 7 AM–2 PM; Tuesday–Saturday: 7 AM–4 PM; Sunday: closed.
- Can you visit Café Pierrot?
- Walk in for breads and pastries, which can sell out. Ready-made 7-inch cakes are in the case daily; call ahead or give at least two days' notice for a specific cake. Cakes and catering can be ordered online for pickup.
Details checked against Café Pierrot’s own site on ; not yet confirmed by the business. Hours change, so check before you go. Spot a mistake? Tell us.


