36 bakeries · 30 towns · updated
We list 36 independent bakeries across 30 towns in Sussex, Morris, Warren, Hunterdon and Somerset counties that bake on the premises: bread, pastry, pies, cakes and cookies. No chains. Each one below is checked against its own website or social pages and its Google Business Profile, with the date we last checked.
Tap a pin for the name and a link. 5 have no public address, so they aren’t on the map. Map data © OpenStreetMap contributors.
Bakery · Andover, Sussex
Café Pierrot’s Andover bakery bakes French breads, croissants and pastries every morning, plus custom cakes, cupcakes and macarons from a Cordon Bleu-trained chef.
Made here: Country French sourdough, baguettes, semolina and rye bread, Croissants, including almond and chocolate, Scones and apple turnovers and more
Bakery · Lafayette, Sussex
A licensed sourdough microbakery in Lafayette selling naturally fermented breads, focaccia and bagels by preorder, plus a Sunday stand at the Lafayette Farmers Market.
Made here: Classic sourdough boules, Sourdough focaccia: jalapeño cheddar, garlic parmesan, rosemary garlic, Sourdough bagels and more
Bakery · Wantage, Sussex
A Wantage bakery, deli and caterer on Route 23 that bakes pies, doughnuts, scones and cupcakes on the premises every morning, open from 5:30 AM on weekdays.
Made here: Fruit and cream pies, including Dutch apple and pumpkin, Doughnuts, crumb cakes and Danish, Scones and muffins and more
Bakery · Wantage, Sussex
A Dutch family bakery on Route 23 near Sussex, open since 1954, baking speculaas, banket and almond pastries from recipes the founders brought from Friesland.
Made here: Speculaas windmill cookies, Krakelingen and Jan Hagel cookies, Banket almond rings and almond stollen and more
Bakery · Chatham, Morris
A Chatham bakery and café on Shunpike Road baking artisan breads, including sourdough, along with custom cakes, cookies and pastries.
Made here: Sourdough bread, Italian bread, French baguettes and ciabatta, Seven grain rounds and semolina bread and more
Bakery · Chester, Morris
A Chester biscotti shop baking a family Sicilian and Neapolitan recipe in more than 25 flavors, including pumpkin, caramel apple and gluten-free biscotti, sold in the shop and shipped.
Made here: Biscotti by the pound: almond, anise, cappuccino, pistachio, lemon, coconut, Nutella, vanilla bean, French toast, s'mores, spumoni, cranberry white chocolate and more, Fall biscotti: pumpkin and caramel apple, Gluten-free double-baked biscotti: funfetti, coconut, lemon, fudge, walnut chocolate chip and mixed and more
Bakery · Chester, Morris
French pâtisserie on Chester’s Main Street run by a fifth-generation pastry chef from Béziers, for croissants, macarons, sourdough and French cakes.
Made here: Croissants and Danish, French pastries, including opera cake, Macarons and more
Bakery · Dover, Morris
A Dover coffee shop and Mexican and Colombian bakery on East Blackwell Street that bakes hojaldras for Día de Muertos and rosca de reyes for Three Kings Day.
Made here: Hojaldras and pan de muerto (October), Rosca de reyes (late December to January 6)
Bakery · East Hanover, Morris
Family-run Italian bakery and deli in East Hanover since 1975, open every day of the year, for custom cakes, Italian pastries and fresh bread.
Made here: Italian bread, Custom and layer cakes, including rum, cannoli and Napoleon cakes, Cannoli and Italian pastries and more
Bakery · Ledgewood, Morris
Italian bakery, deli and pizzeria in a Ledgewood shopping center on Route 10, for bread and rolls, Italian cookies and pastries, and custom cakes.
Made here: Bread and rolls, plus stuffed breads to order, Italian cookies and pastries, Custom, tiered and layer cakes and more
Bakery · Morris Plains, Morris
French bakery and café in Morris Plains from a Lyon-trained pastry chef, for croissants, chocolatines, macarons, apple tarts and afternoon tea.
Made here: Chocolatines and croissants, Viennoiserie, French macarons and more
Bakery · Morristown, Morris
Bakery café off the Morristown Green from pastry chef Uyen Kirshenbaum, with house-made breads, cookies, pastries and sandwiches on their own rolls.
Made here: Hearth-baked breads and Parker rolls, Cookies, Croissants, babka and turnovers and more
Bakery · Morristown, Morris
Morristown bakery and café on South Street, open since 1970, for custom cakes, pies, croissants and pastries plus an all-day halal breakfast and lunch menu.
Made here: Custom and everyday layer cakes, Cupcakes, Pies, including apple, blueberry and key lime and more
Bakery · Belvidere, Warren
A licensed cottage bakery on a small goat farm near Belvidere, baking sourdough loaves and bagels with organic unbleached flour and a homemade starter for a Saturday farm stand and pickup orders.
Made here: Sourdough bread, plain and everything, Sourdough bagels, plain and everything, Gourmet chocolate chip cookies
Bakery · Blairstown, Warren
A Blairstown home baker making sourdough loaves and Portuguese breads and sweets to order for Saturday pickup.
Made here: Sourdough plain loaf, Olive sourdough loaf, Chouriço (chorizo) bread and bacalhau bread and more
Bakery · Blairstown, Warren
Home of River Valley Community Grains and New Jersey's only commercial stone mill, with a Saturday pop-up bakery baking sourdough, cinnamon buns and pastries from its own flour.
Made here: Stone-milled flours: einkorn, hard red wheat, spelt, rye and more, Sourdough breads: country loaves, cranberry walnut and focaccia (Saturdays), Cinnamon buns, cookies, muffins, sweet breads and brownies and more
Bakery · Hackettstown, Warren
A family bakery on Hackettstown’s Main Street since 1985, baking Danish, croissants, crumb buns, cakes and breads from scratch every day.
Made here: Danish and croissants, Muffins and crumb buns, Cookies and cookie trays and more
Bakery · Hackettstown, Warren
The bakery of Treelicious Orchards, making cider doughnuts and fruit pies from the family’s own orchard fruit, plus muffins, quiche and custom cakes.
Made here: Apple cider doughnuts, Fruit pies from orchard fruit, Pumpkin and sweet potato pies in season and more
Bakery · Harmony, Warren
A family micro bakery and small regenerative farm in Harmony baking organic-grain sourdough, croissants and cookies, with raw honey from its own hives and chicken and duck eggs.
Made here: Sourdough breads, $10–$15 depending on inclusions (original, everything, cinnamon raisin and more), Sourdough English muffins, rolls and baguettes (at markets and by request), Sourdough pastries: croissants, pain au chocolat and scones and more
Bakery · Stewartsville, Warren
A Route 519 bake shop in Stewartsville baking pies, breads, cakes, cupcakes, cheesecakes and decorated cookies fresh daily, with gluten-free and vegan options.
Made here: Pies, Breads, Cakes and custom celebration cakes and more
Bakery · Califon, Hunterdon
A Califon cookie shop baking scratch-made cookies in small batches, with gluten-free options, cookie cakes, ice cream and coffee.
Made here: Classic cookies, such as chocolate chunk and snickerdoodles, Giant stuffed and specialty cookies, Italian rainbow, black and white, and linzer cookies and more
Bakery · Flemington, Hunterdon
A Flemington sourdough bakery on Main Street making naturally leavened breads and sourdough croissants from organic, stone-milled flour, with sandwiches and coffee.
Made here: Naturally leavened sourdough breads, such as country, olive and herb, and sesame semolina, Focaccia, Sourdough croissants and Danish and more
Bakery · Frenchtown, Hunterdon
A family-owned Frenchtown bakery on Bridge Street with sourdough breads, fine pastries and custom cakes, open Thursday through Sunday.
Made here: Artisanal sourdough breads, Pastries, Custom cakes and more
Bakery · Lambertville, Hunterdon
A Lambertville artisan bakery for sourdough and multigrain loaves, focaccia, croissants, babka and homemade jams and butters, with all-day brunch sandwiches on its own breads.
Made here: Sourdough country loaves, demi-baguettes and personal loaves, Multigrain seeded loaf, Sea salt and olive focaccia and more
Bakery · Ringoes, Hunterdon
Family cheesecake bakery on Route 31 in Ringoes with a storefront market selling a dozen-plus cheesecake flavors, apple crumb pie and oven-ready meals.
Made here: Cheesecakes, including gluten-free and no-sugar-added, Decorated celebration cheesecakes, Apple crumb pie and more
Bakery · Whitehouse Station, Hunterdon
A small Whitehouse Station bakery making everything from scratch with organic ingredients, known for its Fluffy Cinnamon Rolls, sourdough, scones, cakes and a menu that changes every 6 to 8 weeks.
Made here: Fluffy Cinnamon Rolls, Sourdough, Volcano Sourdough, ciabatta, focaccia and rye sandwich loaves, Scones, including pumpkin and date walnut and more
Bakery · Bound Brook, Somerset
A Mexican bakery and restaurant on Bound Brook's Main Street, known for pan de muerto in sesame and sugar styles each fall and rosca de reyes for Three Kings Day.
Made here: Pan de muerto, with sesame or sugar (October), Rosca de reyes (late December to January 6)
Bakery · Bridgewater, Somerset
A small Bridgewater bakery run by owner-baker Donna Tarnovetchi since 2017, known for custom cakes, macarons and Eastern European pastries like kifli.
Made here: Custom and wedding cakes, Kifli and Eastern European pastries, Breads and more
Bakery · Gladstone, Somerset
A vegan sourdough bread shop and café in Gladstone, baking breads, bagels and pretzels and serving a picnic-style menu of small plates and coffee.
Made here: Sourdough breads, Sourdough bagels, including cheddar jalapeño, Sourdough pretzels and more
Bakery · Hillsborough, Somerset
A Hillsborough bakeshop known for French macarons and custom buttercream cakes, with weekend pre-orders of cinnamon rolls, croissants and gluten-free treats.
Made here: French macarons, including custom colors and monthly flavors, Custom buttercream cakes and wedding cakes, Brioche cinnamon rolls and mini cinnamon rolls and more
Bakery · Manville, Somerset
A family bakery in Manville since 1966, still run by the Karpinski family on the original machines, baking sourdough rye, babka, Danish, doughnuts, pies and cakes.
Made here: Sourdough rye and French bread, Challah, babka and Irish soda bread, to order or in season, Doughnuts and crullers and more
Bakery · Peapack, Somerset
A French-style patisserie on Peapack's Main Street since 2004, baking croissants, baguettes, tarts, tortes and cakes from scratch, with soups, quiche and sandwiches at lunch.
Made here: Croissants, plain, chocolate, almond and savory, Kouign amann, dartois, Danish and apple turnovers, French baguettes and fresh bread daily and more
Bakery · Somerset, Somerset
A Somerset dessert shop on Easton Avenue making custom cakes, cupcakes, cookies and macarons from scratch, with eggless, vegan and peanut-free options.
Made here: Custom cakes and cupcakes, Decorated sugar cookies, French macarons and more
Bakery · Somerville, Somerset
A Somerville cake shop and ice cream counter on West Main Street, making custom and ready-to-go cakes, cupcakes, macarons and its own ice cream.
Made here: Custom and signature cakes, Ice cream cakes, Cupcakes and more
Bakery · Somerville, Somerset
A small-batch dessert bakery on Somerville's Main Street, open since 2021, known for its cannoli brownie and other brownies, plus cupcakes, scones, layer cakes and coffee.
Made here: Brownies, including the cannoli brownie, Cupcakes and cake slices, Four-layer grab-and-go cakes and more
Bakery · Warren, Somerset
A Warren Township sourdough microbakery baking slow-fermented loaves, bagels and cookies from a 100-year-old starter, sold by preorder for local pickup.
Made here: Slow-fermented sourdough loaves, Sourdough pumpkin loaves (fall), Sourdough bagels and more
Bread & Culture (Flemington), Breakthrough Bakery (Warren), Café Pierrot (Andover), Fiddler's Farm & Bakery (Harmony), Hand Baked Treats (Blairstown), Heated (Gladstone), Honey Moon Bakery & Pizzeria (Frenchtown), Hopkins Baking Company (Whitehouse Station), Lambertville Bakehouse (Lambertville), Manville Pastry Shoppe (Manville), Marksboro Mills (Blairstown), NinaLou Patisserie (Chester), The Bread Boutique (Lafayette), The Rustic Roost (Belvidere) and Woodland Bakery & Café (Chatham).
Clove Brook Market (Wantage), Giancarlo’s Bakery (Ledgewood), Just Made Bakery at Treelicious Orchards (Hackettstown), Kirshenbaum Baking Co. (Morristown), Maddalena’s CheeseCake & Catering (Ringoes), Manville Pastry Shoppe (Manville), Sunnie's Bake Shoppe (Stewartsville) and Swiss Chalet Bakery & Café (Morristown).
Somerset 10, Morris 9, Warren 7, Hunterdon 6, Sussex 4.
| Bakery | Town | Known for | Visiting | Checked |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| BAM Desserts | Somerset, Somerset | Custom cakes and cupcakes; Decorated sugar cookies | Book ahead | |
| Blue Sheep Bake Shop & Creamery | Somerville, Somerset | Custom and signature cakes; Ice cream cakes | Walk in | |
| Bread & Culture | Flemington, Hunterdon | Naturally leavened sourdough breads, such as country, olive and herb, and sesame semolina; Focaccia | Walk in | |
| Breakthrough Bakery | Warren, Somerset | Slow-fermented sourdough loaves; Sourdough pumpkin loaves (fall) | Book ahead | |
| Bridgewater Bakery | Bridgewater, Somerset | Custom and wedding cakes; Kifli and Eastern European pastries | Walk in | |
| Café Pierrot | Andover, Sussex | Country French sourdough, baguettes, semolina and rye bread; Croissants, including almond and chocolate | Walk in | |
| Chocolatine | Morris Plains, Morris | Chocolatines and croissants; Viennoiserie | Walk in | |
| Clove Brook Market | Wantage, Sussex | Fruit and cream pies, including Dutch apple and pumpkin; Doughnuts, crumb cakes and Danish | Walk in | |
| CocoLuxe Fine Pastries | Peapack, Somerset | Croissants, plain, chocolate, almond and savory; Kouign amann, dartois, Danish and apple turnovers | Walk in | |
| Cookie Maven | Califon, Hunterdon | Classic cookies, such as chocolate chunk and snickerdoodles; Giant stuffed and specialty cookies | Walk in | |
| Epic Desserts NJ | Somerville, Somerset | Brownies, including the cannoli brownie; Cupcakes and cake slices | Walk in | |
| Fiddler's Farm & Bakery | Harmony, Warren | Sourdough breads, $10–$15 depending on inclusions (original, everything, cinnamon raisin and more); Sourdough English muffins, rolls and baguettes (at markets and by request) | Book ahead | |
| Giancarlo’s Bakery | Ledgewood, Morris | Bread and rolls, plus stuffed breads to order; Italian cookies and pastries | Walk in | |
| Hand Baked Treats | Blairstown, Warren | Sourdough plain loaf; Olive sourdough loaf | Book ahead | |
| Harper’s Bakery | Hackettstown, Warren | Danish and croissants; Muffins and crumb buns | Walk in | |
| Heated | Gladstone, Somerset | Sourdough breads; Sourdough bagels, including cheddar jalapeño | Walk in | |
| Holland American Bakery | Wantage, Sussex | Speculaas windmill cookies; Krakelingen and Jan Hagel cookies | Walk in | |
| Honey Moon Bakery & Pizzeria | Frenchtown, Hunterdon | Artisanal sourdough breads; Pastries | Walk in | |
| Hopkins Baking Company | Whitehouse Station, Hunterdon | Fluffy Cinnamon Rolls; Sourdough, Volcano Sourdough, ciabatta, focaccia and rye sandwich loaves | Walk in | |
| Just Made Bakery at Treelicious Orchards | Hackettstown, Warren | Apple cider doughnuts; Fruit pies from orchard fruit | Walk in | |
| Kirshenbaum Baking Co. | Morristown, Morris | Hearth-baked breads and Parker rolls; Cookies | Walk in | |
| Lambertville Bakehouse | Lambertville, Hunterdon | Sourdough country loaves, demi-baguettes and personal loaves; Multigrain seeded loaf | Walk in | |
| Laura's Coffee & Restaurant | Dover, Morris | Hojaldras and pan de muerto (October); Rosca de reyes (late December to January 6) | Walk in | |
| Linda's Biscotti | Chester, Morris | Biscotti by the pound: almond, anise, cappuccino, pistachio, lemon, coconut, Nutella, vanilla bean, French toast, s'mores, spumoni, cranberry white chocolate and more; Fall biscotti: pumpkin and caramel apple | Walk in | |
| Maddalena’s CheeseCake & Catering | Ringoes, Hunterdon | Cheesecakes, including gluten-free and no-sugar-added; Decorated celebration cheesecakes | Walk in | |
| Manville Pastry Shoppe | Manville, Somerset | Sourdough rye and French bread; Challah, babka and Irish soda bread, to order or in season | Walk in | |
| Marksboro Mills | Blairstown, Warren | Stone-milled flours: einkorn, hard red wheat, spelt, rye and more; Sourdough breads: country loaves, cranberry walnut and focaccia (Saturdays) | Walk in | |
| Melissa's Bakery | Bound Brook, Somerset | Pan de muerto, with sesame or sugar (October); Rosca de reyes (late December to January 6) | Walk in | |
| NinaLou Patisserie | Chester, Morris | Croissants and Danish; French pastries, including opera cake | Walk in | |
| Simply Sweets by Lauren | Hillsborough, Somerset | French macarons, including custom colors and monthly flavors; Custom buttercream cakes and wedding cakes | By appointment | |
| Sorrento Bakery & Deli | East Hanover, Morris | Italian bread; Custom and layer cakes, including rum, cannoli and Napoleon cakes | Walk in | |
| Sunnie's Bake Shoppe | Stewartsville, Warren | Pies; Breads | Walk in | |
| Swiss Chalet Bakery & Café | Morristown, Morris | Custom and everyday layer cakes; Cupcakes | Walk in | |
| The Bread Boutique | Lafayette, Sussex | Classic sourdough boules; Sourdough focaccia: jalapeño cheddar, garlic parmesan, rosemary garlic | Book ahead | |
| The Rustic Roost | Belvidere, Warren | Sourdough bread, plain and everything; Sourdough bagels, plain and everything | Book ahead | |
| Woodland Bakery & Café | Chatham, Morris | Sourdough bread; Italian bread, French baguettes and ciabatta | Walk in |
Every place here is independent and based in the Skylands. Each listing is checked against the business’s own website or social pages and its Google Business Profile; “confirmed” means the business has reviewed it too. Hours change, so check before you go.How we check · Know one we missed? Suggest it.
