In our guides
Featured in Traditional Holiday Foods
- Stir-up Sunday: Mincemeat pies
Carol Kesler opened Just Made Bakery in October 1997 using family recipes, with fruit from Treelicious Orchards, the Kesler family’s 130-acre orchard in Port Murray. The bakery hand-peels and slices apples for its pies, and its fruit pies are vegan with no preservatives. It also bakes muffins, cookies, brownies, carrot cake, quiche and chicken pot pie, and is a peanut-free facility with sugar-free and gluten-free versions of most items.
What’s here
- Made here
- Apple cider doughnuts · Fruit pies from orchard fruit · Pumpkin and sweet potato pies in season · Quiche and chicken pot pie · Muffins, cookies and brownies · Custom decorated cakes
- Sold here from other producers
- Fresh-pressed cider from Treelicious Orchards
This season
Pumpkin and sweet potato pies are on the seasonal list alongside cider doughnuts.
Good to know
- Where is Just Made Bakery at Treelicious Orchards?
- 1892 Route 57, 6 Riverside Plaza, Hackettstown, NJ 07840, in Warren County.
- When is Just Made Bakery at Treelicious Orchards open?
- Tuesday–Saturday: 9 AM–2 PM; Sunday–Monday: closed; Evenings by appointment.
- Can you visit Just Made Bakery at Treelicious Orchards?
- Walk in Tuesday through Saturday at the shop in Riverside Plaza, across Route 57 from Walmart. Custom cakes and special requests by phone or email; orders can also be placed online or with the PDF order form.
Details checked against Just Made Bakery at Treelicious Orchards’ own site on ; not yet confirmed by the business. Hours change, so check before you go. Spot a mistake? Tell us.

