In our guides
Featured in Traditional Holiday Foods
- Advent: Linzer cookies and vanilla crescents
Cookie Maven bakes cookies from scratch in small batches at its shop on County Road 513 in Califon. The case runs from classics like chocolate chunk and snickerdoodles to stuffed giant cookies, Italian rainbow cookies and linzers, plus a gluten-free line that includes pignoli and almond horns. The shop also sells ice cream, brewed coffee, gifts and local art, and takes cookie cake orders.
What’s here
- Made here
- Classic cookies, such as chocolate chunk and snickerdoodles · Giant stuffed and specialty cookies · Italian rainbow, black and white, and linzer cookies · Gluten-free cookies, including pignoli and almond horns · Cookie cakes
- Sold here from other producers
- Gifts and work by local artists
- Served here
- Ice cream · Brewed coffee
This season
Thanksgiving orders are due by Saturday, November 21: download the order form and email it to info@cookiemavenbaking.com or text (646) 641-7322; payment finalizes the order. Pumpkin snickerdoodles and ginger molasses cookies are on the seasonal menu. Open Wednesday and Thursday 10 AM to 7 PM, Friday and Saturday 10 AM to 9 PM and Sunday 9 AM to 2 PM.
Good to know
- Where is Cookie Maven?
- 427 County Road 513, Unit 3, Califon, NJ 07830, in Hunterdon County.
- When is Cookie Maven open?
- Monday–Tuesday: closed; Wednesday–Thursday: 10 AM–7 PM; Friday–Saturday: 10 AM–9 PM; Sunday: 9 AM–2 PM.
- Can you visit Cookie Maven?
- Walk in during shop hours. Cookie cakes need 2–3 days' notice: email or text the shop to order.
Details checked against Cookie Maven’s own site on ; not yet confirmed by the business. Hours change, so check before you go. Spot a mistake? Tell us.
