In our guides
Hayek's Market was founded by Elias Hayek in 1939 and is now run by Dan and Denise Hayek. It is a full independent market on Mill Street in Newton, open seven days, with groceries, a butcher counter, and a deli that makes salads, paninis and ready-to-eat dinners daily. The bakery makes pies, cookies and cakes and takes custom orders, and the ice cream parlor next door serves a rotating list of handcrafted flavors, from vanilla and chocolate to seasonal ones. The kitchen also caters, with holiday menus for Thanksgiving, Christmas and other occasions, and there are daily lunch and dinner specials and a monthly dinner menu.
What’s here
- Made here
- Deli salads, paninis and ready-to-eat dinners · Bakery pies, cookies and cakes, with custom orders · Handcrafted ice cream in rotating and seasonal flavors · Catering and holiday menus: soups, roast turkey, homemade turkey gravy, sides
- Sold here from other producers
- Butcher counter cuts · Groceries and deli meats · Gift baskets
- Served here
- Ice cream parlor · Lunch and dinner specials to go
This season
Open year-round, Monday to Saturday 7 AM to 7:30 PM and Sunday 7 AM to 6 PM. Thanksgiving orders are due by Sunday, November 22 (allow at least 24 hours), online or by phone: whole Jaindl roast turkeys from $125 (14 lb) to $269 (30 lb), a 7 lb breast $79, turkey dinners $23.99 each and pies from $18.99. The Christmas menu is up too, with short ribs, glazed ham and beef tenderloin; allow 48 hours.
Good to know
- Where is Hayek's Market?
- 1 Mill Street, Newton, NJ 07860, in Sussex County.
- When is Hayek's Market open?
- Monday–Saturday, 7 AM–7:30 PM; Sunday, 7 AM–6 PM.
- Can you visit Hayek's Market?
- Walk in. The market is open seven days. Online ordering with delivery is available through the market's ordering page. For catering, the market asks for two weeks' notice around holidays.
Details checked against Hayek's Market’s own site on ; not yet confirmed by the business. Hours change, so check before you go. Spot a mistake? Tell us.

