A Dutch apple crumb pie with a slice cut, beside fresh apples and butter (stock photo)

Farm · Vernon, Sussex County

Heaven Hill Farm

A Vernon farm market and bakery on Route 94, known for its cider donuts and long list of fruit and cream pies, with greenhouses and a big fall festival out back.

Official site Directions →

Stock photo: Patrick Fore / Unsplash

The Theobald family bought this 365-acre Vernon farm in 1961 and raised beef cattle into the late 1970s. In 1982 Martin Theobald set up a roadside tent to sell the produce he grew, and the business grew into Heaven Hill Farm, with a barn market, a bakery and four greenhouses. The bakery turns out fresh cider donuts, pies (apple, caramel apple walnut, Dutch apple, seasonal pumpkin, blueberry, cherry, very berry, strawberry rhubarb, coconut custard and no-sugar apple and blueberry), tea breads, danish, strudel sticks, muffins and cookies, and the market scoops homemade ice cream and Italian ices.

What’s here

Made here
Apple cider donuts · Pies, including seasonal pumpkin and no-sugar-added apple and blueberry · Tea breads: pumpkin, banana nut, zucchini nut, cinnamon and corn · Danish, strudel sticks and muffins · Cookies · Homemade ice cream and Italian ices · Handmade wreaths in December
Grown or raised here
In-season fruits and vegetables · Vegetables and herbs in the greenhouses · Annuals, perennials and hanging baskets
Sold here from other producers
Local meats, including Fossil Farm · Cheeses and hard salamis · Savory pot pies · Jams, jellies, honey, sauces, salsas and pickles · Stonewall Kitchen products · Balic wines · Christmas trees from other growers (Fraser and balsam fir)
Served here
Homemade ice cream and Italian ices · Ready-to-eat baked goods

This season

Holiday pies are ordered by phone: call (973) 764-5144. The farm market is open daily 9 AM to 5 PM with pies and cider donuts. In December the market turns to Christmas trees, custom handmade wreaths, roping and grave blankets.

Good to know

Where is Heaven Hill Farm?
451 State Route 94, Vernon, NJ 07462, in Sussex County.
When is Heaven Hill Farm open?
Farm market, bakery and garden center: daily, 9 AM–6 PM (the market page lists 9 AM–5 PM); Great Pumpkin Festival, Sep 12–Nov 8, 2026: October weekdays 11 AM–5 PM, weekends 10 AM–6 PM; final weekend in November 10 AM–5 PM; December market (2025 listing): daily, 9 AM–5 PM.
Can you visit Heaven Hill Farm?
Walk in to the market and bakery. The Great Pumpkin Festival is a separate ticketed event on the same property through Nov 8, 2026; service animals only at festivals. In December, trees are fresh-cut, wrapped and tied to your car at no charge.

Details checked against Heaven Hill Farm’s own site on ; not yet confirmed by the business. Hours change, so check before you go. Spot a mistake? Tell us.

Skylands Food newsletter

You’ve driven past it a hundred times.

A farm baking with a 22-year-old sourdough starter named Cooper. New Jersey’s only Grade A goat dairy. The Skylands Food newsletter finds the food worth pulling over for.

Free. Unsubscribe anytime. Privacy

Tell us

Suggest a place or event

Know a farm, maker, restaurant or food event in the Skylands we should cover? The best tips come from people who live here.

What are you suggesting?
The place
The event

Everything is checked before it's published. How we choose.

My Skylands trip

Take your trip with you.

We’ll email every stop now, with hours, how to visit and your route, so it’s on your phone when you go.

Free. You’ll also get the Skylands Food newsletter. Unsubscribe anytime. Privacy

    Saved on this device. Add farms, makers, places to eat and drink, and events from any page. The route starts from where you are.