In our guides
The Theobald family bought this 365-acre Vernon farm in 1961 and raised beef cattle into the late 1970s. In 1982 Martin Theobald set up a roadside tent to sell the produce he grew, and the business grew into Heaven Hill Farm, with a barn market, a bakery and four greenhouses. The bakery turns out fresh cider donuts, pies (apple, caramel apple walnut, Dutch apple, seasonal pumpkin, blueberry, cherry, very berry, strawberry rhubarb, coconut custard and no-sugar apple and blueberry), tea breads, danish, strudel sticks, muffins and cookies, and the market scoops homemade ice cream and Italian ices.
What’s here
- Made here
- Apple cider donuts · Pies, including seasonal pumpkin and no-sugar-added apple and blueberry · Tea breads: pumpkin, banana nut, zucchini nut, cinnamon and corn · Danish, strudel sticks and muffins · Cookies · Homemade ice cream and Italian ices · Handmade wreaths in December
- Grown or raised here
- In-season fruits and vegetables · Vegetables and herbs in the greenhouses · Annuals, perennials and hanging baskets
- Sold here from other producers
- Local meats, including Fossil Farm · Cheeses and hard salamis · Savory pot pies · Jams, jellies, honey, sauces, salsas and pickles · Stonewall Kitchen products · Balic wines · Christmas trees from other growers (Fraser and balsam fir)
- Served here
- Homemade ice cream and Italian ices · Ready-to-eat baked goods
This season
Holiday pies are ordered by phone: call (973) 764-5144. The farm market is open daily 9 AM to 5 PM with pies and cider donuts. In December the market turns to Christmas trees, custom handmade wreaths, roping and grave blankets.
Good to know
- Where is Heaven Hill Farm?
- 451 State Route 94, Vernon, NJ 07462, in Sussex County.
- When is Heaven Hill Farm open?
- Farm market, bakery and garden center: daily, 9 AM–6 PM (the market page lists 9 AM–5 PM); Great Pumpkin Festival, Sep 12–Nov 8, 2026: October weekdays 11 AM–5 PM, weekends 10 AM–6 PM; final weekend in November 10 AM–5 PM; December market (2025 listing): daily, 9 AM–5 PM.
- Can you visit Heaven Hill Farm?
- Walk in to the market and bakery. The Great Pumpkin Festival is a separate ticketed event on the same property through Nov 8, 2026; service animals only at festivals. In December, trees are fresh-cut, wrapped and tied to your car at no charge.
Details checked against Heaven Hill Farm’s own site on ; not yet confirmed by the business. Hours change, so check before you go. Spot a mistake? Tell us.

