In our guides
Pete and Marilyn Southway’s Jersey and Guernsey cows are milked in a barn that sits directly above the creamery: the milk travels by tubing from the parlor to the vat downstairs. That is about as short a trip from cow to cheese as you will find in New Jersey.
The specialty is soft farmstead cheese in a dozen flavors (garlic pepper, tomato basil, everything bagel and more), plus flavored cheese curds and glass-bottled cream-line milk.
What’s here
- Made here
- Original farmstead cheese · Garlic pepper · Hot pepper · Tomato basil · Everything bagel · Flavored cheese curds
- Grown or raised here
- Cow (the farm’s own Jerseys & Guernseys)
Who uses or sells it
- Best's Fruit Farm, Hackettstown: milk and cheese, sold at the farm
As named by each business.
Good to know
- Where is Springhouse Creamery?
- 85 Phil Hardin Road, Newton, NJ 07860, in Sussex County.
- When is Springhouse Creamery open?
- Self-serve farm shop, reported open around the clock.
- Can you visit Springhouse Creamery?
- Walk in. Self-serve farm shop: pick up and pay on the honor system. No tours are posted.
- Where else can you find food from Springhouse Creamery?
- Best's Fruit Farm in Hackettstown.
Details checked against the business’s own listings on ; not yet confirmed by the business. Hours change, so check before you go. Spot a mistake? Tell us.


