Sinterklaas comes on the evening of Saturday, December 5, 2026, and St. Nicholas Day is Sunday, December 6. In the Skylands, Holland American Bakery in Wantage bakes banket in alphabet letters from November through New Year, speculaas it calls Sinter Klaas cookies, and taai taai. The German Christmas Market of New Jersey falls on the same weekend, December 4 to 6, at the Sussex County Fairgrounds.
Chocolate letters and pepernoten are mostly imported; we found no local shop posting them yet. If you know one, tell us.
Almond letter and banket
Puff pastry wrapped around almond paste and baked in the shape of the first letter of your name.

Photo: Holland American Bakery Posted this seasonDutch bakery since 1954 · Wantage, Sussex
Holland American Bakery
Banket, flaky pastry around a tube of almond paste, baked in alphabet letter shapes from November through New Year’s. The almond letter is the classic Sinterklaas gift. The everyday ring is $10.25.
“A light pastry crust surrounds an inside tube of almond paste. Definitely a holiday treat! Just like you remember your grandmother made. Special alphabet shapes offered from November through the New Year.”
How to get it: Call (973) 875-5258 or stop in to order a letter (initials sell out near December 5). The ring ships from the online shop. 246 Route 23, Wantage. (973) 875-5258.
Speculaas
Crisp spice cookies pressed in wooden molds, often of St. Nicholas himself or a windmill.

Posted this seasonDutch bakery since 1954 · Wantage, Sussex
Holland American Bakery
Speculaas windmill cookies, which the bakery itself calls Sinter Klaas cookies, their best seller. $10.55.
“Also known as Sinter Klaas cookies or windmill cookies - these crunchy spice cookie are always a perfect addition to your coffee or tea time. One of our top 3 best sellers!”
How to get it: Walk in or order online for shipping. 246 Route 23, Wantage. (973) 875-5258.
Taai taai
A chewy, dense cookie of honey and anise, often shaped like the saint, his horse or a doll.

Posted this seasonDutch bakery since 1954 · Wantage, Sussex
Holland American Bakery
Taai taai, the chewy honey and anise cookie of Sinterklaas, three to a pack, in the Holiday Specialties section. $6.75.
“This is an old world Dutch treat. Its a type of bar that is made with honey and anise seed.”
How to get it: Order online or ask in the shop. 246 Route 23, Wantage. (973) 875-5258.
Temples, parishes and community gatherings
Where the food is part of the celebration.
Posted this seasonNonprofit German Christmas market · Augusta, Sussex
German Christmas Market of New Jersey
The German Christmas market falls on Sinterklaas weekend and Nikolaustag, December 4 to 6, with German food in the St. Nicholas Hall food barn and a German Cookie Hut.
“Authentic wooden huts, traditional bratwurst and German food, hand-crafted artisanal gifts, live choirs, and festive entertainment for the whole family.”
Details: Friday, December 4 and Saturday, December 5, 10 AM to 8 PM; Sunday, December 6, 10 AM to 5 PM. Tickets online; free parking. Sussex County Fairgrounds, 37 Plains Road, Augusta. 973-264-9336.
About Sinterklaas foods
Sinterklaas is the Dutch feast of St. Nicholas, whose name day is December 6. Gifts come the evening before, on pakjesavond, which in 2026 is Saturday, December 5. The foods are small and spiced: pepernoten and kruidnoten, speculaas cookies, chocolate initials, almond-filled banket, marzipan figures and mandarin oranges.
Pepernoten are small, square and light brown, made from rye flour, sugar and anise, sometimes with cinnamon and clove. They are fairly chewy and harden as they sit out, and they are often confused with kruidnoten, the small, round, gingerbread-like cookies. Handfuls are thrown to the crowd when Sinterklaas arrives in mid-November, and at home they are tossed across the room for children to find. Children also leave a shoe out with a carrot or some hay for his horse.
Speculaas is a spice cookie from the Low Countries, flavored with cinnamon and often nutmeg, clove, ginger, cardamom and black pepper, and traditionally pressed with carved wooden molds. Eating it around St. Nicholas’ feast is an old custom, and some is filled with almond paste. The Belgian speculoos trades the spices for caramelized sugar, and Germans call the spiced kind Spekulatius. The name grew out of the older Dutch speculatie, which once meant pleasure and was used for fine baked goods.
Each child gets a chocolate letter, their first initial. The banketletter is the pastry version: puff pastry or a butter dough around almond paste, dusted with sugar and shaped like a letter, originally the initial of the family name. In the United States, where it is served through December, the S has become the most common shape. Sinterklaas is one of the sources of the American Santa Claus, and the Saint Nicholas Society of New York still holds a feast every December 6.
Still looking: know who makes these?
- Chocolate letters (chocoladeletters). Holland American lists Dutch candy and chocolate clogs, but no chocolate letters online. Ask in the shop.
- Pepernoten and kruidnoten. Not listed by any Skylands bakery or shop. Ask Holland American.
- Stutenkerl or Weckmann. No German bakery in the five counties lists the St. Nicholas bread man.
- A Sinterklaas visit or party. No Dutch club, church or school event found in the five counties.
Questions people ask
Is Sinterklaas Santa Claus?
Sinterklaas is not Santa Claus, but he is one of Santa's sources. Sinterklaas is the Dutch feast of St. Nicholas, whose name day is December 6, and gifts come the evening before, on pakjesavond, which in 2026 is Saturday, December 5. The Saint Nicholas Society of New York still holds a feast every December 6.
What are traditional Dutch sweets?
The traditional Sinterklaas sweets are pepernoten and kruidnoten, speculaas cookies, chocolate initials, almond-filled banket, marzipan figures and mandarin oranges. Pepernoten are small, chewy squares of rye flour, sugar and anise, while kruidnoten are small, round and crunchy like gingerbread. Each child gets a chocolate letter, their first initial.
Where can I buy speculaas cookies?
In the Netherlands speculaas is sold as a Sinterklaas treat from late summer until St. Nicholas' feast in early December, so look for it at Dutch and European bakeries and import grocers in late November. Ask for gevulde speculaas, the kind filled with almond paste, as well as the plain spiced cookie.
What is the difference between speculaas and speculoos?
Speculaas is the Dutch spice cookie and speculoos is the Belgian version, which drops the traditional spices in favor of caramelized sugar. Speculaas is flavored with cinnamon and often nutmeg, clove, ginger, cardamom and black pepper, and is traditionally pressed in carved wooden molds. Germans call the spiced kind Spekulatius.
What is a banketletter?
A banketletter is a Dutch almond pastry shaped like a letter: puff pastry or a butter dough wrapped around almond paste and dusted with sugar. It was originally shaped as the initial of the family name. In the Netherlands it is eaten through December, especially on Sinterklaas evening, December 5, and in the United States the S has become the most common shape.
Every listing quotes the business or organization’s own post or page, with its date; we checked them on . Holiday plans change, so confirm before you go. Spot a mistake, or make one of these foods? Tell us.
