Wheels of golden Califon Tomme cheese on a wicker tray with walnut bread, grapes and jam

Farmstead creamery · Long Valley, Morris County

Valley Shepherd Creamery

New Jersey’s best-known sheep dairy, with more than twenty cheeses and an aging cave 26 feet under the hillside.

Official site Directions →

Photo: Valley Shepherd Creamery

Valley Shepherd has been making cheese in Long Valley since 2005 from its own grass-fed sheep, plus goat and Jersey cow milk. There are no cheesemaking machines here: the milk is warmed, cultured and cut by hand in open vats.

The wheels age in a cave dug 26 feet into the hillside. The weekend cave-wagon tour takes you there by wagon ride, after a look at the cheesemaking room, barn and milking parlor.

What’s here

Made here
Oldwick Shepherd (sheep) · Pepato (sheep) · Tartufo Shepherd (sheep) · Califon Tomme (cow) · Valley Thunder (cow) · Nettlesome
Grown or raised here
Sheep (the farm’s own flock)

Restaurants that cook with it

  • d'Floret, Lambertville: cheese (named in the menu's sourcing line, not tied to a dish)

As named on each restaurant’s menu or supplier list.

This season

Cave-wagon tours every Saturday and Sunday at 1:30 PM through November 7, 2026. Adults $9.95, children under 12 $9, or $21.95 with a cheese tasting tray for two. Book online by Thursday morning for Saturday, Friday morning for Sunday. Rain or shine; bring your own wine or beer.

Good to know

Where is Valley Shepherd Creamery?
50 Fairmount Road, Long Valley, NJ 07853, in Morris County.
When is Valley Shepherd Creamery open?
Thursday–Saturday: 10 AM–5 PM; Sunday: 11 AM–5 PM; Monday–Wednesday: closed.
Can you visit Valley Shepherd Creamery?
Walk in to the Sheep Shoppe during store hours. Cave tours must be booked online in advance.
Where else can you find food from Valley Shepherd Creamery?
d'Floret in Lambertville.

Details checked against Valley Shepherd Creamery’s own site on ; not yet confirmed by the business. Hours change, so check before you go. Spot a mistake? Tell us.

Skylands Food newsletter

You’ve driven past it a hundred times.

A farm baking with a 22-year-old sourdough starter named Cooper. New Jersey’s only Grade A goat dairy. The Skylands Food newsletter finds the food worth pulling over for.

Free. Unsubscribe anytime. Privacy

Tell us

Suggest a place or event

Know a farm, maker, restaurant or food event in the Skylands we should cover? The best tips come from people who live here.

What are you suggesting?
The place
The event

Everything is checked before it's published. How we choose.

My Skylands trip

Take your trip with you.

We’ll email every stop now, with hours, how to visit and your route, so it’s on your phone when you go.

Free. You’ll also get the Skylands Food newsletter. Unsubscribe anytime. Privacy

    Saved on this device. Add farms, makers, places to eat and drink, and events from any page. The route starts from where you are.