Branchville
Jersey Girl Cheese at Hillcrest Orchard & Dairy
Fresh hand-stretched mozzarella, caciocavallo and scamorza from the farm’s own Jersey cows
Farm store open all winter, Wednesday to Sunday
Photo courtesy of Jersey Girl Cheese
Stock photo: Prchi Palwe / Unsplash
Thanksgiving 2026 · Shop local, course by course
The Thanksgiving Table
Every course of your Thanksgiving dinner, from the farms, butchers, bakeries and markets near you. Pick your county, choose your stops, and we’ll map the route.
Your Sussex Thanksgiving countdown
- NowReserve your turkey at Waterwheel or Glenwood Mountain
- Wed 11/18Last day to order Sussex Meat Packing’s Thanksgiving dinner
- Sat 11/21Sparta Thanksgiving Market · Waterwheel turkey pickup begins
- Sun 11/22Glenwood Mountain turkey pickup, 11 AM to 4 PM
- Mon 11/23Last turkey pickups at both farms
- Thu 11/26Thanksgiving Day. Pochuck Valley is closed, so shop earlier in the week
Course 01
Appetizers
Farm cheese, pickles and smoked things to nibble while the bird roasts.
Newton
Springhouse Creamery
Flavored farmstead cheese and cheese curds for the board
Self-serve farm shop on the honor system
Stock photo: olimpia campean / Unsplash
Course 02
Main Course
Farm-raised turkeys, plus a cooked bird or a roast if you’d rather not.
Newton
The Stables at Waterwheel Farm
Fresh free-range Broad Breasted Bronze turkeys, about 18 to 30+ lb, $6 a pound
Order now. Pickup Saturday 11/21, Sunday 11/22 or Monday 11/23 at the farm
Stock photo: Dan Dennis / Unsplash
Sussex
The Farm at Glenwood Mountain
Pasture-raised turkeys from a chef-run farm that raises only 175 a year, $7.95 a pound
$50 deposit to reserve. Pickup Sunday 11/22, 11 AM to 4 PM, or Monday 11/23, 3 to 7 PM
Photo: The Farm at Glenwood Mountain
Sussex
Sussex Meat Packing
A complete turkey dinner cooked for you: sliced turkey, gravy, sausage stuffing, mashed potatoes, vegetables and rolls, from $160.99 (serves 4 to 5) to $524.99 (16 to 20)
Order by Wednesday 11/18 (2026 menu). Half trays of sides sold separately
Stock photo: Hayley Ryczek / Unsplash
Also selling turkeys: Flatbrook Farm and LL Pittenger Farm. Check their sites for order details.
Course 03
Sides
Potatoes, squash, Brussels sprouts and greens, picked this month.
Sussex
JADS Farm Market
Potatoes, sweet potatoes, onions, Brussels sprouts, kale and winter squash from the black dirt
Open daily 9 AM to 5 PM through December 31
Stock photo: Sharon Pittaway / Unsplash
Wantage
Kittatinny Mountain Farm
Certified organic winter squash, leeks, Brussels sprouts, root vegetables and greens
At the Sparta Farmers Market every Saturday through 11/28
Photo: Kittatinny Mountain Farm
Course 04
Stuffing & Gravy
Good bread, local sausage and gravy you didn’t have to make.
Andover
Café Pierrot
French breads baked every morning, the base for a proper stuffing
Tuesday to Saturday from 7 AM; breads can sell out
2026 order deadline not posted yet. Ask when you order.
Photo: Café Pierrot
Wantage
Wormuth Farm
Pastured pork sausage and bacon for the stuffing
Order online, pick up at the farm on a weekend
2026 order deadline not posted yet. Ask when you order.
Stock photo: Kelsey Todd / Unsplash
Newton
Hayek's Market
Homemade gravy, sides and pies from the Thanksgiving catering menu
Last year’s menu is posted (orders were due 11/23/2025); 2026 not posted yet
Stock photo: Rebecca Matthews / Unsplash
Course 05
Dessert
Pies from farm bakeries. Some must be ordered ahead.
Newton
Windy Brow Farms
Fruit crumble pies from the orchard bakery, made with their own apples
Farm store open daily 9 AM to 6 PM, through late December
2026 order deadline not posted yet. Ask when you order.
Photo: Windy Brow Farms
Vernon
Heaven Hill Farm
Pumpkin pies and cider donuts from the farm bakery
Market and bakery open daily
2026 order deadline not posted yet. Ask when you order.
Stock photo: Patrick Fore / Unsplash
Glenwood
Pochuck Valley Farms Market & Deli
Pies from Diana’s Bakery, including sugar-free
All pies are preordered by phone. Last year: orders 11/1 to 11/21. Closed Thanksgiving Day
2026 order deadline not posted yet. Ask when you order.
Stock photo: Priscilla Du Preez / Unsplash
Course 06
Drinks
Fresh cider, local wine and something from the distillery for after.
Wantage
Green Valley Farms Market & Creamery
Fresh apple cider from the Wantage farm market
Open Monday to Saturday 9 AM to 9 PM, Sunday noon to 7:30 PM
Stock photo: Abhishek singh / Unsplash
Wantage
Ventimiglia Vineyard
Small-batch, oak-aged wines made on a Wantage farm
Saturday noon to 5 PM, Sunday noon to 4 PM
Stock photo: Ruben Mavarez / Unsplash
Branchville
Milk Street Distillery
Grain-to-glass bourbon, rye and gin for after dinner
Friday 4 to 10 PM, Saturday 1 to 10 PM, Sunday 1 to 6 PM
Photo: Milk Street Distillery
One stop, every course
Sussex Thanksgiving market days
SaturdayNov 21
Sparta Thanksgiving Market
9 AM to 1 PM · Sparta
Kittatinny Mountain Farm’s vegetables, pastured meats, cheese and bread in one stop.
Your Warren Thanksgiving countdown
- NowReserve a turkey at Hope Cress Farms, Beaver Brook Ranch or Arctic Foods, and order pies at Donaldson Farms
- Fri 11/13Beaver Brook Ranch turkey pickup, Friday 11/13 or Saturday 11/14
- Sat 11/14Last Blairstown Farmers’ Market of the year
- Sun 11/15Four Fields Farm pickup in Hackettstown: sausage for the stuffing
- Tue 11/17Last day to order an Arctic Foods prepared dinner
- Sat 11/21Marksboro Mills pop-up bakery: bread for the stuffing
- Thu 11/26Thanksgiving Day. Arctic Foods (also closed Friday) and Czig Meister are closed, so finish shopping by Wednesday
Course 01
Appetizers
Farm cheese, pickles and smoked things to nibble while the bird roasts.
Asbury
Riverine Ranch
Water buffalo mozzarella, stracciatella and ricotta from the farm’s own herd
By appointment, so email or call before you drive out
Stock photo: Orkun Orcan / Unsplash
Blairstown
Alpine Meats and Deli
Smoked cheeses, smoked salmon and landjäger from the shop’s two smokehouses, for a German-style board
Tuesday to Friday 8 AM to 5:30 PM, Saturday 8 AM to 4 PM
Stock photo: Lieana Slapinsh / Unsplash
Hackettstown
Kilhaney's Pickles
House-made pickles, pickled onions and spicy beet pickled eggs for the relish tray
Tuesday to Saturday 11 AM to 6 PM, Sunday 11 AM to 4 PM
Photo: Kilhaney's Pickles
Course 02
Main Course
Farm-raised turkeys, plus a cooked bird or a roast if you’d rather not.
Hope
Hope Cress Farms
Fresh, pasture-raised Thanksgiving turkeys, about 20 lb, $6.68 a pound
Preorders open now online with a $40 deposit, balance at pickup. Pickup dates not posted yet
Stock photo: Hayley Ryczek / Unsplash
Blairstown
Beaver Brook Ranch
Pasture-raised heritage Bronze turkeys, 16 to 28 lb, raised on the family’s Blairstown ranch, $7.75 a pound
$50 deposit online. Pickup Friday 11/13 or Saturday 11/14 at the ranch (or 11/21), or shipped 11/16
Stock photo: William Stark / Unsplash
Washington
The Meat Shoppe at Arctic Foods
A fully prepared turkey dinner made in the store ($300 and $360), or a fresh, never frozen, pasture-raised turkey from Ferndale Market in Minnesota, cut by a full-service butcher at a USDA plant
Prepared dinners by Tuesday 11/17, pickup 11/24 or 11/25. Turkeys $5.59 a pound, $20 deposit, pickup 11/20 to 11/25. Closed Thursday and Friday, 11/26 and 11/27 (confirmed by Amanda at Arctic Foods)
Stock photo: Lois Spencer Carter / Unsplash
Also selling turkeys: Rath's Butcher & Delicatessen, Four Fields Farm, Cotton Cattle Company and Alpine Meats and Deli. Check their sites for order details.
Course 03
Sides
Potatoes, squash, Brussels sprouts and greens, picked this month.
Great Meadows
Godlewsky Farms & Greenhouses
Celery, onions, leeks, carrots and winter vegetables from the Great Meadows muck fields
Monday to Saturday 9 AM to 6 PM, Sunday 10 AM to 4 PM
Stock photo: David Trinks / Unsplash
Asbury
Cabbage Throw Farm
Certified organic sweet potatoes, potatoes, carrots, cabbage and fall greens
Farm store at Kash Valley Farm, Thursday and Friday 2 to 6 PM, through December
Stock photo: Beth Macdonald / Unsplash
Course 04
Stuffing & Gravy
Good bread, local sausage and gravy you didn’t have to make.
Blairstown
Marksboro Mills
Cranberry walnut sourdough and country loaves baked from the mill’s own stone-ground flour
Saturday pop-up bakery 9 AM to 3 PM; Sat 11/21 is the last one before Thanksgiving
2026 order deadline not posted yet. Ask when you order.
Stock photo: Debbie Widjaja / Unsplash
Great Meadows
Four Fields Farm
Nitrate-free sage sausage from forest-raised pork, made for the stuffing
Order online for pickup: on the farm Nov 8, or Hackettstown and South Orange Nov 15
Stock photo: Chelsea shapouri / Unsplash
Washington
The Meat Shoppe at Arctic Foods
Store-made stuffings, potatoes, squash and Brussels sprouts by the pound
Order sides with your turkey; pickup 11/20 to 11/25. Closed Thursday and Friday, 11/26 and 11/27
Stock photo: Marshalok Brend / Unsplash
Course 05
Dessert
Pies from farm bakeries. Some must be ordered ahead.
Hackettstown
Donaldson Farms
Pumpkin, pecan and Honey Crisp apple pies, from more than 20 kinds baked in the farm market
2026 pie orders open now by phone (908-852-9122 ext 1) or at the market. All orders final
Stock photo: Kelsey Weinkauf / Unsplash
Belvidere
Mackey's Orchard
The five-pound Mile High apple pie, or a pumpkin or apple crumb pie, from the orchard bakery
Daily 9 AM to 5:30 PM; the apple bakery runs through December
2026 order deadline not posted yet. Ask when you order.
Stock photo: stephanie monfette / Unsplash
Hackettstown
Just Made Bakery at Treelicious Orchards
Pumpkin and sweet potato pies, plus fruit pies from TreeLicious orchard fruit
Tuesday to Saturday 9 AM to 2 PM; order by phone or online
2026 order deadline not posted yet. Ask when you order.
Stock photo: Kelsey Weinkauf / Unsplash
Course 06
Drinks
Fresh cider, local wine and something from the distillery for after.
Milford
Alba Vineyard
Estate Riesling and Pinot Noir, two wines made for the turkey
Open daily from 11 AM
Photo: Alba Vineyard
Port Murray
TreeLicious Orchards
Fresh-pressed cider from 73 varieties of their own apples
The Barn at the orchard, Saturday 9 AM to 5 PM and Sunday noon to 5 PM
Stock photo: Aleksandra Gencheva / Unsplash
Hackettstown
Living Spirits Craft Distillery
Bending Branch Brandy, distilled from peaches, for after dinner
Bottles to take home, Wednesday to Sunday
Photo: Living Spirits Craft Distillery
One stop, every course
Warren Thanksgiving market days
SaturdayNov 14
Blairstown Farmers’ Market, last market of the season
9:30 AM to 1 PM · Blairstown
The final Saturday market, 12 days before Thanksgiving: stock up on storage vegetables, mushrooms, cheese and meats.
Your Morris Thanksgiving countdown
- NowReserve a turkey at Ashley Farms or call Chester Meat Market
- Mon 11/16Last day to order SMP Sussex Market’s Thanksgiving menu
- Sat 11/21Madison Farm & Artisan Market, 9 AM to 2 PM
- Sun 11/22Last Denville and Morristown farmers markets of the season
- Wed 11/25SMP Sussex Market pickup, 9 AM to 1 PM
- Thu 11/26Thanksgiving Day. Wightman Farms is open 8 AM to noon; Alstede and Stony Hill are closed
Course 01
Appetizers
Farm cheese, pickles and smoked things to nibble while the bird roasts.
Long Valley
Valley Shepherd Creamery
Cave-aged sheep’s milk cheeses like Oldwick Shepherd, Pepato and Tartufo Shepherd, from the farm’s own flock
Sheep Shoppe open Thursday to Saturday 10 AM to 5 PM, Sunday 11 AM to 5 PM
Photo: Valley Shepherd Creamery
Morris Plains
Jersey Artisan Co.
Fresh burrata, mozzarella and aged primo sale made from Spring Run Dairy milk
Morris Plains cafe open Tuesday to Saturday 7 AM to 8 PM, Sunday 8 AM to 5 PM; order ahead online
Photo: Jersey Artisan Co.
Butler
Polski Smak
House-made kielbasa and pierogi to slice and pan-fry before dinner
Monday to Friday 6 AM to 6 PM, Saturday 7 AM to 5 PM; call ahead to order
Stock photo: Eugene Kucheruk / Unsplash
Course 02
Main Course
Farm-raised turkeys, plus a cooked bird or a roast if you’d rather not.
Flanders
Ashley Farms
Fresh turkeys raised and processed on the farm, 14 to 45 lb, $4.99 a pound, plus pies at $17.99
Order now by phone or the farm’s online form, by size group; no cutoff posted
Stock photo: Lois Spencer Carter / Unsplash
Chester
Chester Meat Market
Fresh all-natural turkeys and holiday roasts, cut to order on Main Street
Taking holiday orders now: call (908) 879-7523 and order early. 2026 deadline not posted
Stock photo: Hayley Ryczek / Unsplash
Wharton
SMP Sussex Market
Fresh Jaindl turkeys, sliced turkey breast in gravy ($59.95 a half tray), or a $16.95 single-serve Thanksgiving dinner
Turkeys: order now, pickup 11/23 to 11/25. Prepared menu: order by Monday 11/16, pickup Wednesday 11/25, 9 AM to 1 PM. Closed Thanksgiving
Stock photo: Chelsea shapouri / Unsplash
Also selling turkeys: Stony Hill Farms. Check their sites for order details.
Course 03
Sides
Potatoes, squash, Brussels sprouts and greens, picked this month.
Chester
Alstede Farms
Certified organic potatoes, sweet potatoes, beets and collard greens from the Chester fields
Farm store open daily 9 AM to 6 PM; closed Thanksgiving Day
Stock photo: Alexandr Podvalny / Unsplash
Chester
Riamede Farm
Butternut, delicata, honeynut and kojinut squash for roasting
November hours 9 AM to 4:30 PM, Wednesday to Monday
Stock photo: Elijah Pilchard / Unsplash
Denville
Union Hill Farms
Winter squash, leeks, cauliflower and root vegetables from Morris County’s oldest farm
Roadside stand open daily; also at the Morristown and Denville markets Sunday 11/22
Stock photo: Blair Fraser / Unsplash
Course 04
Stuffing & Gravy
Good bread, local sausage and gravy you didn’t have to make.
Wharton
SMP Sussex Market
Classic country sausage stuffing ($29.95 a half tray) and roasted turkey gravy ($8.99 a quart)
Order by Monday 11/16. Pickup Wednesday 11/25, 9 AM to 1 PM
Stock photo: Chelsea shapouri / Unsplash
Mendham
Backer Farm
Pasture-raised sweet Italian or maple sausage for the stuffing, and bone broth for the gravy
Self-serve farm stand open daily 9:30 AM to 5:30 PM
2026 order deadline not posted yet. Ask when you order.
Stock photo: Louis Hansel / Unsplash
Denville
Cedar Gate Farm
Farm sourdough loaves to cube and dry for stuffing
Weekends 10 AM to 6 PM; order online by Thursday 8 PM for weekend pickup
2026 order deadline not posted yet. Ask when you order.
Photo: Cedar Gate Farm
Course 05
Dessert
Pies from farm bakeries. Some must be ordered ahead.
Long Valley
Ort Farms
Pumpkin pie, the bakery’s top seller at Thanksgiving, plus pecan and caramel apple walnut
Farm market open daily 9 AM to 7 PM through December 31
2026 order deadline not posted yet. Ask when you order.
Stock photo: Lois Spencer Carter / Unsplash
Randolph
Sun High Orchards
Apple pies baked daily in the farm store kitchen, with the orchard’s own apples
Open daily through New Year’s Eve, weekdays 10 AM to 6 PM, weekends 9 AM to 6 PM
2026 order deadline not posted yet. Ask when you order.
Stock photo: fountain Pen / Unsplash
Mendham
Miller's Hill Farm
Freshly baked Thanksgiving pies, made to order
Pies are order-ahead; call or check the farm’s site for flavors and pickup
2026 order deadline not posted yet. Ask when you order.
Stock photo: fountain Pen / Unsplash
Course 06
Drinks
Fresh cider, local wine and something from the distillery for after.
Morristown
Wightman Farms
Cold-pressed sweet cider from the farm’s own blend of apples, no preservatives
Open Thanksgiving morning, 8 AM to noon
Stock photo: Aleksandra Gencheva / Unsplash
Chester
Rebel Sheep Wine Co.
Cranberry, blueberry and peach fruit wines and hard cider from Stony Hill Farms fruit
Thursday and Friday 2 to 8 PM, Saturday noon to 8 PM, Sunday noon to 6 PM
Stock photo: Kaley Dykstra / Unsplash
Morristown
Dismal Harmony Distilling
House amaro, coffee liqueur or Vidisha’s Masala liqueur for after the pie
Tuesday to Sunday from 4 PM, weekends from noon; 21+
Photo: Dismal Harmony Distilling
One stop, every course
Morris Thanksgiving market days
SaturdayNov 21
Madison Farm & Artisan Market
9 AM to 2 PM · Madison
Alstede’s and Melick’s produce, Gorgeous Goat cheese, breads and Grandma Emma’s pies, the Saturday before Thanksgiving. It keeps going into December.
SundayNov 22
Denville Farmers’ Market
8:30 AM to 1 PM · Denville
Last main-season market: Union Hill vegetables, R&M Farm pastured meats, Bobolink cheese and bread.
SundayNov 22
Morristown Farmers Market
8:30 AM to 1 PM · Morristown
The season’s last market: organic produce, Haring Family Farm meat, Jersey Artisan cheese and sourdough, and Honey Bunch Farm honey.
Your Hunterdon Thanksgiving countdown
- NowReserve a pasture-raised turkey at Kingspring Farm (only a few left), or ask Haring or Haxton about theirs
- Tue 11/10Last day to order Maddalena’s Thanksgiving dinner and pies
- Sat 11/21Cheese run: Sugar Maple Jerseys, 10 AM to 4 PM
- Sun 11/22Hunterdon Community Farmers Market, 9 AM to 1 PM: Gorgeous Goat cheese pickup, last regular market of the year
- Wed 11/25Last shopping day: sausage at Elite Meat, 9 AM to 5 PM
- Thu 11/26Thanksgiving Day. Hardly any of these farms post holiday hours, so finish shopping by Wednesday
Course 01
Appetizers
Farm cheese, pickles and smoked things to nibble while the bird roasts.
Stockton
Gorgeous Goat Creamery
Fresh chèvre in herbes de Provence or black pepper and garlic, goat’s milk feta and aged goat Gouda from New Jersey’s only Grade A goat dairy
Farm store weekends through 10/31. After that, order online by Wednesday night and pick up at the Hunterdon Community Farmers Market, Sundays 9 AM to 1 PM
Photo courtesy of Gorgeous Goat Creamery (Shilp Iyer Photography)
Stockton
Sugar Maple Jerseys
Aged raw milk cheddar (try the smoked or garlic dill), smoked gouda, cheese curds and hand-made butter from a grass-fed Jersey herd
The Farmer’s Table is open Thursday and Friday 11 AM to 3 PM, Saturday and Sunday 10 AM to 4 PM
Stock photo: Aliona Gumeniuk / Unsplash
Milford
Bobolink Dairy & Bakehouse
A wedge of raw milk Amram or Endgame from a 100% grass-fed herd, and a heritage-grain sourdough loaf to go with it
Cheesemaking runs only April to November, so fall is the last chance for fresh wheels. Closed Tuesdays
Photo courtesy of Bobolink Dairy & Bakehouse
Course 02
Main Course
Farm-raised turkeys, plus a cooked bird or a roast if you’d rather not.
Stockton
Kingspring Farm
A pasture-raised Thanksgiving turkey from a small Stockton flock, processed right on the farm, $8 a pound
Only 7 left as of October 18: message or call 908-528-3174 to reserve, ready for Thanksgiving
Stock photo: Dan Dennis / Unsplash
Frenchtown
Haring Family Farm
A pasture-raised turkey from a Frenchtown farm that raises its birds without chemicals or antibiotics
Their online shop lists a pasture-raised turkey at $140; no 2026 sizes or pickup dates posted, so email the farm
Stock photo: Zulfugar Karimov / Unsplash
Stockton
Haxton Homestead
Whole pasture-raised Thanksgiving turkeys from a small Stockton homestead
Last year: $7.50 a pound. 2026 details not posted yet, so message the farm to reserve
Stock photo: Lois Spencer Carter / Unsplash
Also selling turkeys: Rambo's Country Store. Check their sites for order details.
Course 03
Sides
Potatoes, squash, Brussels sprouts and greens, picked this month.
Milford
Phillips Farms
Apples, Asian pears and fall vegetables from the farm’s own coolers, plus their jams and fresh bread
Farm Market open daily, 9 AM to 6:30 PM, into winter
Stock photo: Bovia & Co. Photography / Unsplash
Asbury
Central Valley Farm
Fall vegetables and brown eggs from a fifth-generation Bethlehem Township farm, with local butter and cheese at the stand
Farm stand open daily, 9 AM to 6 PM
Photo: Central Valley Farm
Course 04
Stuffing & Gravy
Good bread, local sausage and gravy you didn’t have to make.
Clinton
Elite Meat
Hot, sweet or breakfast sausage from a Clinton butcher with more than 40 years in the trade
Wednesday to Saturday 9 AM to 5 PM, Sunday 10 AM to 3 PM; call (908) 200-7350 to order ahead
2026 order deadline not posted yet. Ask when you order.
Stock photo: Chelsea shapouri / Unsplash
Whitehouse Station
Hopkins Baking Company
Sourdough croutons and breadcrumbs baked from scratch with organic ingredients, a head start on the stuffing
Friday 9:30 AM to 4:30 PM, Saturday and Sunday 8 AM to 3 PM; Tuesday to Thursday preorder pickup by appointment
2026 order deadline not posted yet. Ask when you order.
Stock photo: Robert Stump / Unsplash
Flemington
Bread & Culture
Country and olive and herb sourdough loaves, naturally leavened over several days, to cube for a proper stuffing
Thursday to Sunday, 9 AM to 2 PM; bread sells until gone and there’s no preorder, so come early
2026 order deadline not posted yet. Ask when you order.
Stock photo: Tommaso Urli / Unsplash
Course 05
Dessert
Pies from farm bakeries. Some must be ordered ahead.
Ringoes
Sweet Valley Farms
Pies baked in the farm market of a Ringoes family farm working its land since 1928
Monday to Saturday 8 AM to 6 PM, Sunday 9 AM to 5 PM; holiday hours are posted on the farm’s Facebook and Instagram
2026 order deadline not posted yet. Ask when you order.
Stock photo: Anna Voss / Unsplash
Ringoes
Maddalena’s CheeseCake & Catering
Pumpkin cheesecake and the apple crumb pie that won People’s Choice at the Allentown Fair Pie Wars, or a whole Thanksgiving dinner with the turkey sent home hot
Order by Tuesday 11/10 (paid in full by 11/6). Pickup Thanksgiving morning
Photo: Maddalena’s CheeseCake & Catering
Course 06
Drinks
Fresh cider, local wine and something from the distillery for after.
Oldwick
Melick's Town Farm, Oldwick Cider Mill
Fresh cider, Melick’s own hard cider and wine, and pies from the Oldwick Farm Market, all grown on the family’s orchards
Oldwick Farm Market, 170 Oldwick Road: open daily 9 AM to 6 PM, year round
Stock photo: Bonnie Kittle / Unsplash
Ringoes
Unionville Vineyards
Estate Pinot Noir and Chardonnay, two easy matches for turkey
Open daily 12 to 5 PM, and wine orders can be picked up any day. Closed Thanksgiving Day, so stock up by Wednesday (confirmed by John Cifelli, general manager)
Photo: Unionville Vineyards
Pittstown
Spring Run Dairy
Eggnog from the farm’s own Jersey and Holstein milk, back for the season, and cream-top whole milk for the coffee
Eggnog runs Thanksgiving through Christmas. Self-serve farm store open daily; cash or Venmo
Stock photo: Mary Skrynnikova / Unsplash
One stop, every course
Hunterdon Thanksgiving market days
SundayNov 22
Hunterdon Community Farmers Market
9 AM to 1 PM · Flemington
The last regular market of the year, the Sunday before Thanksgiving, on Dvoor Farm in Flemington: pastured meat from Haring, goat cheese, Seasonal Sarah’s pies and Unionville wine.
Your Somerset Thanksgiving countdown
- NowReserve a turkey at Griggstown, River Bend or Lima Family Farms
- Sat 10/24Zell’s Farm holiday mushroom CSA begins; sign up before it starts
- Sat 11/21Griggstown turkey pickup begins · Bernardsville and Bedminster markets
- Tue 11/24River Bend and Lima Family Farms turkey pickups
- Wed 11/25Last day for Griggstown pickups
- Thu 11/26Thanksgiving Day. Abma’s is closed, and Lima Family Farms opens Friday to Sunday only, so shop there by Sunday 11/22
Course 01
Appetizers
Farm cheese, pickles and smoked things to nibble while the bird roasts.
Branchburg
River Lea House
Black garlic, Garlickles and pickled Brussels sprouts with black garlic butter and hummus for the board, from a 190-year-old Branchburg garlic farm
Sundays 10 AM to 1 PM at the Somerville farmers market (last market 11/22), or order online to ship
Photo: River Lea House
Manville
The Polish Pickle Deli
Homemade low-salt pickles, beet horseradish and kielbasa for a Manville-style starter plate
Monday to Friday 9 AM to 6 PM, Saturday 8 AM to 4 PM
Stock photo: Anshu A / Unsplash
Course 02
Main Course
Farm-raised turkeys, plus a cooked bird or a roast if you’d rather not.
Princeton
Griggstown Farm
Farm-raised white Broad Breasted turkeys from $4.79 a pound or heirloom Black turkeys, plus capon, duck and goose
$20 deposit per bird, online, by phone or in the store. Pickup Saturday 11/21 to Wednesday 11/25
Photo: Griggstown Farm
Far Hills
River Bend Farm
Pasture-raised Bronze turkeys from the family’s Gladstone Valley flock
Preorder only, and they sell out. Pickup Tuesday 11/24, the Tuesday before Thanksgiving
Stock photo: William Stark / Unsplash
Hillsborough
Lima Family Farms
A turkey raised on the farm, $7.25 a pound, with its own bacon, ham and sausage from the farm’s butcher shop
$40 deposit at the farm store, by phone or email. Pickup Tuesday 11/24, 12 to 5 PM, or Wednesday 11/25, 10 AM to 2 PM
Stock photo: Dan Dennis / Unsplash
Also selling turkeys: Three Meadows Farm, Skillman Farm Market and Butcher Shop, Norz Hill Farm & Market and Hind & Fore. Check their sites for order details.
Course 03
Sides
Potatoes, squash, Brussels sprouts and greens, picked this month.
Liberty Corner
English Farm
Certified organic butternut, delicata and acorn squash, sweet potatoes, potatoes, shallots and kale
Farm store Thursday and Friday noon to 4 PM, Saturday and Sunday 11 AM to 4 PM
Stock photo: Elijah Pilchard / Unsplash
Hillsborough
Zell's Farm
Maitake, chestnut, lion’s mane and golden oyster mushrooms to roast or fold into the stuffing
Holiday mushroom CSA runs through 12/26; farm store Friday 11 AM to 5 PM, Saturday and Sunday 10 AM to 4 PM
Photo: Zell's Farm
Hillsborough
Abma's Farm (Hillsborough)
Homemade sides and scratch-baked goods from the farm kitchen
Last year: Thanksgiving pre-order store, pickup 11/24 to 11/26 at the Hillsborough market; 2026 not posted yet. Closed Thanksgiving Day
Stock photo: Sebastian Coman Photography / Unsplash
Course 04
Stuffing & Gravy
Good bread, local sausage and gravy you didn’t have to make.
Princeton
Griggstown Farm
Traditional turkey gravy, au jus gravy with fresh herbs, cranberry sauce and Sweet Mama’s cornbread
Order with your bird; pickup Saturday 11/21 to Wednesday 11/25
Photo: Griggstown Farm
Bridgewater
Hind & Fore
Hand-made sweet Italian sausage with no fillers, for a proper sausage stuffing
Tuesday to Saturday; call ahead for holiday orders
2026 order deadline not posted yet. Ask when you order.
Stock photo: Marshalok Brend / Unsplash
Bernardsville
Butcher & Farmer
Breakfast and sweet Italian sausage made from scratch, and brioche baked in house every day
Tuesday to Saturday 10 AM to 8 PM
2026 order deadline not posted yet. Ask when you order.
Stock photo: Kelsey Todd / Unsplash
Course 05
Dessert
Pies from farm bakeries. Some must be ordered ahead.
Hillsborough
Hillsboro Farm Country Market
Thanksgiving pies baked to order in the farm kitchen: apple, Dutch apple, pumpkin and pecan
Orders taken every November, by phone or in person only. Tuesday to Sunday 10 AM to 5 PM
2026 order deadline not posted yet. Ask when you order.
Stock photo: Kavya P K / Unsplash
Manville
Manville Pastry Shoppe
Pumpkin, apple and coconut custard pies from a family bakery baking since 1966
Pies rotate, so call ahead or place an order. Closed Mondays
2026 order deadline not posted yet. Ask when you order.
Stock photo: Element5 Digital / Unsplash
Peapack
CocoLuxe Fine Pastries
A pear frangipane or salted caramel tart from Peapack’s French patisserie
Tarts need 48 hours’ notice: call (908) 781-5554, option 2
2026 order deadline not posted yet. Ask when you order.
Photo: CocoLuxe Fine Pastries
Course 06
Drinks
Fresh cider, local wine and something from the distillery for after.
Bedminster
Burnt Mills Cider
Dry sparkling hard cider for the table, and Apple Fizz, a 0.0% cider, for everyone else
Wednesday 4 to 8 PM, Thursday and Friday 4 to 9 PM, Saturday noon to 9 PM, Sunday noon to 6 PM
Photo: Burnt Mills Cider
Somerville
Middlemist Honey Wine & Cider
Local Wildflower mead and honey cider brewed on Somerville’s Main Street
Monday from 5 PM, Tuesday to Friday from 2 PM, Saturday and Sunday from noon
Photo: Middlemist Honey Wine & Cider
Hillsborough
Bellemara Distillery
Single malt whiskey made from 100% malted barley, for after the pie
Thanksgiving week: Wednesday 11/25, 4 to 11 PM. Closed Thanksgiving Day. Friday 11/27, 2 to 11 PM
Photo: Bellemara Distillery
One stop, every course
Somerset Thanksgiving market days
SaturdayNov 21
Bernardsville Farmers’ Market
9 AM to 1 PM · Bernardsville
The last summer market of the season, the Saturday before Thanksgiving: farms, pasture-raised meat, soups, breads and pickles at the train station.
SaturdayNov 21
Bedminster Farmers Market
9 AM to 1 PM · Bedminster
About 50 farms and food makers at River Road Park, River Bend Farm among them. The market runs again Nov 28 and closes with a Holiday Market Dec 5.
How we chose
Every stop on the Thanksgiving Table had to clear the same bar: it’s in Sussex, Warren, Morris, Hunterdon or Somerset County, it sells to you directly, it’s open through Thanksgiving week, and everything we say about it comes from the business itself, on its own website or from the owner.
Then we ranked them, the same way in every county:
- Confirmed by the owner. Businesses that checked their listing and sent us their holiday details come first.
- 2026 details posted. Order deadlines, pickup days and prices for this year beat last year’s, or none.
- Grown, raised or made here. Farms that raise their own turkeys, and kitchens and bakeries that make what they sell, rank above places that resell. Look for Raised on the farm.
- Spread across the county, so there’s a good stop near you.
- One ready-cooked dinner per Main Course, for anyone who would rather not roast.
Each course has at most three stops per county. Other good places selling turkeys are named under each Main Course. We list order and pickup dates only when the business has posted them, and where only last year’s details are up, we say so.
Checked against each business’s own website on . Holiday plans change, so confirm before you drive. Run a farm, butcher or bakery in the Skylands? Send us your holiday dates.